Collectors
- ISAMAYA Luckykiss Lip Glow, Buck (best overall) · See price on Amazon
- ISAMAYA Rubberlash Mascara (best mascara) · See price on Amazon
- ISAMAYA Wild Star Pressed Pigment Palette (best for colour) · See price on Amazon
Full reasoning, verified listing details, and a comparison table below.
Prices are shown on Amazon at click-through. We may earn a commission.
How We Picked
We work only from what each live Luxury storefront listing states at capture. Our storefront search for the brand returned five listings — our search, not a census — and every one we opened is "Sold by ISAMAYA BEAUTY and Fulfilled by Amazon," which is the brand as seller of record with Amazon handling logistics: a meaningful line, but not the same thing as Amazon selling the product itself. Every listing we opened shows free returns. Because these Beauty listings publish ratings, we used them the way ratings should be used at this scale — as one input, cited with the count, never as a ranking on their own — and ordered the guide by the strength of what each listing publishes: ingredient list, stated claims, and the one rating base that reaches double figures. The lipstick-and-pencil set, at 3.4 stars from 4 ratings, is held as an alternate.
This is the site's first makeup-brand guide; our Beauty coverage so far has been skincare and hair, and the method here is the one used in the Clé de Peau guide, which also cites thin rating bases beside every figure, and in our luxury skincare roundup. The site's editorial policy explains why we will not paper over a 3.6.
1. Best Overall: ISAMAYA Luckykiss Lip Glow, Buck
ISAMAYA Luckykiss Lip Glow, Buck
ISAMAYA
- Rated 3.9 stars across 16 ratings at capture — the largest base and highest average of the four ISAMAYA listings we opened
- Balm-texture lipstick with a two-tone pearlescent finish; the listing says it can be worn alone or over lipstick
- Contains vitamin E (tocopheryl acetate in the published ingredient list) — the listing's hydration claim
- Full ingredient list published; vegan and cruelty-free formula per the listing; Made in Italy
- Shade Buck captured; the listing refers to three shades
- Sold by ISAMAYA BEAUTY and Fulfilled by Amazon; free returns shown
Why we picked it: Best overall here means the listing that gives a buyer the most to go on, and this one does: a full ingredient list, a clear description of what the product is — a cushiony balm-texture lipstick with glittering pearl pigments and a two-tone pearlescent finish — and the deepest rating base of the brand's storefront presence at 3.9 stars from 16 ratings. Sixteen is still a small number and we would not call 3.9 strong; Amazon's own generated review summary on the page says buyers find the colour's appearance gorgeous and give value for money mixed feedback, and that reads like a fair account of a 3.9. The vitamin E the listing advertises is checkable as tocopheryl acetate in the published ingredients, which is the kind of claim we like: one you can verify on the page. The listing mentions three shades; only Buck is captured here. If you buy one ISAMAYA product to see whether the line is for you, this is the one with the least uncertainty around it.
2. Best Mascara: ISAMAYA Rubberlash Mascara
ISAMAYA Rubberlash Mascara
ISAMAYA
- Rated 3.6 stars across 9 ratings at capture — a thin base and a middling average, disclosed as such
- Described as a lifting mascara using what the listing calls a proprietary latex lift technology; the published ingredient list does not name a latex or rubber ingredient
- The listing claims up to 16 hours of smudge-proof wear with no smearing or flaking; no test is cited
- Full ingredient list published; vegan and cruelty-free formula per the listing; Made in Italy
- Sold by ISAMAYA BEAUTY and Fulfilled by Amazon; free returns shown
Why we picked it: Rubberlash is the brand's mascara and the listing's pitch is lift — lashes stretched up and out, sculpted one by one, like a lash lift in a tube. We report that as the listing's language. Two things a careful buyer should weigh: the claim of up to 16 hours of smudge-proof wear cites no test, and the latex lift technology the description names does not correspond to any ingredient called latex or natural rubber in the ingredient list the same page publishes — the list is a conventional wax-and-polymer mascara formula with carnauba wax, acrylates copolymer and panthenol. The listing does not explain the phrase further, and we would rather you knew. At 3.6 stars from 9 ratings the storefront's own buyers are lukewarm on a base too small to trust either way. The formula is fully disclosed, it is made in Italy, and it is the only mascara the brand lists here, which is why it holds the position.
3. Best for Colour: ISAMAYA Wild Star Pressed Pigment Palette
ISAMAYA Wild Star Pressed Pigment Palette
ISAMAYA
- Rated 3.6 stars across 6 ratings at capture — the thinnest base of the three; disclosed, not weighted
- Twelve pressed pigment shades in a gilded, rhinestone-embellished case, per the listing
- The listing says pigments can be applied with fingers or a brush, on eyes or face, and intensified with water or used as liner
- Vegan and cruelty-free per the listing, with the brand's own exclusion: the Canter shade is excluded from the vegan claim
- No ingredient list published on the page — the listing says to see packaging; item weight 5 ounces
- Sold by ISAMAYA BEAUTY and Fulfilled by Amazon; free returns shown
Why we picked it: This is the brand's statement piece and the listing reads like it: twelve shades, a gilded rhinestone case, prairie-glam and rodeo nights. Underneath the copy the facts are thinner than on the other two picks. There is no ingredient list on the page — the listing tells you to see the packaging — and the vegan claim carries an asterisk the brand prints itself, excluding the Canter shade, which we repeat because a buyer who cares about vegan formulas needs to know it. The specification table also lists the item form as liquid and the age range as kid, neither of which matches a pressed eyeshadow palette; we treat those as listing data errors and do not repeat them as facts. The rating is 3.6 stars from 6, and of the three reviews visible at capture one praised the quality of the shadows and one said the compact felt like cheap plastic for the price. Six ratings settle nothing. What is verifiable is the format, the shade count, the case, the origin, and the exclusion — buy it for the colour, with your eyes open about how little the page tells you beyond that.
Comparison Table
| Pick | Rating at capture | What the listing publishes | Claims to note | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Luckykiss Lip Glow, Buck | 3.9 stars from 16 ratings | Full ingredient list; vegan and cruelty-free; Made in Italy | Vitamin E hydration (tocopheryl acetate in the list); three shades referenced | See price |
| Rubberlash Mascara | 3.6 stars from 9 ratings | Full ingredient list; vegan and cruelty-free; Made in Italy | Up to 16 hours smudge-proof (no test cited); latex lift technology (no latex in the list) | See price |
| Wild Star Pressed Pigment Palette | 3.6 stars from 6 ratings | No ingredient list (see packaging); Made in Italy; 5 oz | Vegan except the Canter shade, per the brand; table lists liquid and kid, both errors | See price |
What to Look For
Reading a 3.6 from six ratings honestly The ratings on these listings are real and we cite them, but a base of six or nine or sixteen is not evidence of much beyond the fact that a handful of people bought and rated the product. Our rule is to disclose the count beside every figure and never let a thin base carry a recommendation, in either direction: a 3.6 from 6 does not condemn a palette any more than a 4.9 from 6 would prove one. What a middling average on a small base does tell you is that early buyers were not unanimously delighted, which is consistent with the visible reviews on the palette — one loved the shadows, one thought the case felt cheap. Read the numbers as a caution to expect a mixed experience, then decide on the formula facts the listings do publish.
Ingredient lists are where these listings earn or lose trust Two of the three picks publish a full ingredient list, and that is the most useful thing on either page: it lets you check the marketing against the label. The lip glow's vitamin E is there as tocopheryl acetate; the mascara's latex lift is not there as any latex ingredient, and the listing does not explain the phrase. The palette publishes no list at all and refers you to the packaging, which in an online purchase means you find out after it arrives. If you have sensitivities or a vegan requirement, the two listed formulas can be checked before buying; the palette cannot, and its own vegan claim excludes one shade.
Vegan, cruelty-free, Made in Italy: which claims are checkable All three listings state vegan and cruelty-free formulas and Made in Italy. Made in Italy is a labelling claim we take as stated. The vegan and cruelty-free claims are the brand's; no certifying body is named on any of the pages, so we report them as the listing's claims rather than as verified certifications. The palette's exclusion of the Canter shade is the brand being more precise than most, and we credit that. Where a listing names a certifier, we say so; none of these do.
Seller line and returns: what the storefront guarantees here Every ISAMAYA listing we opened reads Sold by ISAMAYA BEAUTY and Fulfilled by Amazon. That means the brand is the seller of record and Amazon stores and ships the item — Amazon logistics, not Amazon as the seller, and not a third-party marketplace reseller either. Free returns are shown on every listing we opened, which matters more than usual for a brand whose storefront ratings are mixed: the practical risk of trying a lip glow or a mascara is a return, and the listings make that route explicit.
Bottom Line: Which Should You Buy?
Best overall: the ISAMAYA Luckykiss Lip Glow, Buck — the fullest listing and the deepest base — a balm-texture pearlescent lipstick with a published formula, rated 3.9 from 16 at capture.
Best mascara: the ISAMAYA Rubberlash Mascara — a fully disclosed wax-and-polymer lifting formula, Made in Italy, with a 16-hour wear claim we report as the listing's own — 3.6 from 9 at capture.
Best for colour: the ISAMAYA Wild Star Pressed Pigment Palette — twelve shades in a rhinestone case, no ingredient list on the page and a vegan claim that excludes one shade — 3.6 from 6 at capture.
Ready to buy?
Jump straight to our picks on Amazon — current prices shown at click-through.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ISAMAYA Beauty worth it?
On the storefront's own numbers, buyers are mixed: 3.9 stars from 16 ratings on the lip glow, 3.6 from 9 on the mascara, 3.6 from 6 on the palette, and 3.4 from 4 on the lipstick-and-pencil set. Those bases are too small to settle the question either way. What the listings do offer is full ingredient disclosure on two products, Made in Italy on every listing we opened, and free returns, which make trying one product a low-risk way to answer it for yourself.
Is ISAMAYA makeup vegan and cruelty-free?
Each listing states a vegan and cruelty-free formula, and no certifying body is named, so these are the brand's claims. The Wild Star palette's listing adds its own exclusion — the Canter shade is not covered by the vegan claim. If a certification matters to you, the pages do not provide one.
Who sells ISAMAYA on Amazon?
Every listing we opened reads Sold by ISAMAYA BEAUTY and Fulfilled by Amazon: the brand is the seller of record and Amazon handles storage and shipping. That is not the same as Amazon selling the product first-party, but it is also not an anonymous marketplace seller. Free returns were shown on every listing we opened at capture.
What is the Rubberlash latex lift technology?
It is the listing's phrase for the mascara's lifting effect. The ingredient list the same page publishes contains no ingredient named latex or natural rubber — it is a wax-and-polymer formula with carnauba wax, acrylates copolymer and panthenol. The listing does not explain the phrase further.
Does the Wild Star palette publish its ingredients?
No. The listing says to see the packaging for the full ingredient list, so you cannot check the formula before buying online. Its specification table also lists the item form as liquid and the age range as kid, both of which appear to be data errors for a pressed eyeshadow palette. The lip glow and mascara listings, by contrast, publish complete ingredient lists.
Related Guides
How We Research
Picks are based on the specifications each live listing publishes, brand standing, and the rating figures the listings publish, captured at the time of research and disclosed with their counts. Listings, ratings, and stock change — confirm current details at the retailer before buying.
Beauty ratings note: Unlike the Luxury fashion listings behind our other guides, these Beauty listings publish customer ratings, and we cite them exactly as captured on 19 September 2026 — 3.9 from 16, 3.6 from 9, and 3.6 from 6 — beside their counts, because bases this thin cannot carry a recommendation on their own. Listings, ratings, and stock change; confirm current details on the live page before buying.